Perry, 30, and Arencibia, 28, got married at the First Presbyterian Church in the singer's hometown of Greenville, Tenn.
The MLB player proposed in October at Perry's parents' house in Greenville. Arencibia popped the question under a large oak tree in the backyard.
"He's just a really gentle soul. He balances me for sure," Perry said after the engagement.
The pair met backstage at a meet-and-greet for the band in 2012.
Watch This Tonight: See why Jessie is today's editors' pick: